Consensus between judiciary and legislature to boost investors’ trust

It was not just the cancellation of 122 odd licenses awarded by a dishonest telecom minister, but was much more than that. In 2012, when the honorable Supreme Court announced revocation of 2G spectrum almost 80 million customers; banks who lent INR 30,000 crore to five firms; companies who shared infrastructure; and foreign investors including Norway’s Telenor and Russia’s Sistema went into a state of anarchy. This is not a single incident that led to an environment wherein stakeholders lost trust in the Indian market. Now criticizing the same does not mean that the same should not have happened. Justice, for sure, is above anyone’s interest or loss. But am I wrong in saying that ‘economy’ is a synonym of ‘country’? And for a stable economy, surety of business is indispensable. The mistake, of course, was committed by the legislatures, but what about the sufferers who followed the prescribed regulations and extended money and labor? I can remember what Justice AK Ganguly, added to his verdict, ‘I am only doing my job’, knowing the ruin that the judgment would do to the Indian corporate sector.

Recent is the Apex Court’s judgment in the Coalgate scam where the honorable judges scrapped 214 coal blocks and ordered auction of the same post 6 months of judgment. Prior to coming to the consequences, let us notice that the court also asked companies to pay INR 295 per tonne of coal they extract and that too with retrospective effect. In case you had prepared the budgets and forecasts for the year, please rework. We are all aware of the scarcity of coal with power plants and the subsequent impact on Indian industrial sector. Also, households are paying hefty charges for electricity. Banks, which extended loans to companies, will suffer from steeply rising bad debt liability (Indian banking sector has an exposure of more than INR 5 lakh crore to the power sector). Of all the banks, the public sector bank, PNB has a peak exposure at 2.6 per cent of total advances to the mining sector. Others are the NBFCs ranging from REC and IDFC to the Power Finance Corporation. Something vital to note from the judgment are the words of the honorable judge, ‘There was no proper application of mind in distribution of coal blocks’. Plus, the court commented on lack of transparency and paramount irregularity.

We all agree that the honorable court accorded supreme place to justice. And integrity, indeed, must prevail. Nevertheless, the pain of those who without any fault fall into the grip of helplessness is something that in case not taken care of can fade away even the tough labors of the new Indian PM. ‘Make in India’ can succeed, but business security is the foremost essential. Even the susceptible stock market has a safety device, Investor Protection Fund to defend investors. Then how can the fund-seeking corporate sector of India prove detrimental to investors who extend substantial capital? But the democratic arrangement places judiciary above all, which in fact is lawful too. Who then is at fault? Yes we all know. They, however, are at fault since decades. Something relaxing, if has happened in the recent past, is the verdict of courts against high-profile politicians, put behind the bars. The rest, however, will learn, is not assured. Another depressing fact is the statement given by S&P’s credit analyst that Supreme Court’s ruling in the Coalgate can hurt significantly improved investor sentiments towards Indian corporate sector.

World Bank has lately predicted India’s economic growth at 6.4 per cent in the FY 2015-16 and has also said that the country is benefitting from ‘Modi dividend’. Share market is bullish and so are the entrepreneurs, but the recent conclusion by the Apex Court in the Coalgate scam has probed many in-house weaknesses. Remember, overseas fund-providers will not just rely on the pluses of the new government at the center. Rather, while finalizing strategic restructuring and investment visions, the due diligence report focuses on all-around factors that can upset the venture in the long-run. The new Act for the corporate sector, as known to all, is packed with gaps and holdbacks. Then we have lack of consensus between the union and state governments. Scarcity of adequate infrastructure is apparent. Then can we also bear the burden of revocation of concluded business deals? INR 2.87 lakh crore, as submitted by private companies, is the amount that they invested in coal extraction projects. Now, the GOI is seeking legal opinion in the matter of annulment of title deeds and forfeiting of bank guarantees. Mess, all over.

Anything we say, the judiciary will do its job, rightful and intact, and this is what we all expect from our honorable wing of democracy. A workable resolution can be agreement between the judiciary and the legislative wing. What about setting a threshold limit for business transactions that involve government and private players as parties, and then placing a supervisory judicial board to assure arm’s length dealing? From the beginning till the conclusion of such business deals, a judicial personality should have the power to administer, and upon completion, such deals should become unalterable. Along with, the government can set up a board, with legislative and judicial members, to prepare a due diligence report of hefty dealings. Once approved, corporate players must have the immunity from being harassed or penalized later. An Investor Education and Protection Fund can be created which shall be funded from the compulsory CSR aid. The Fund will advise domestic and overseas investors beyond resolving grievances and making good any authentic loss to the corporate houses. Let us hope that the new government and the new CJI will think over the prevailing pulls in the Indian market and will curb them.

Lastly, can I request India’s honorable and worthy judges to also notice the pain of the corporate houses, their shareholders, and employees prior to declaring a deal void ab initio? There is no harm in assessing the overall impact of a decision, though we respect the fact that the judiciary bears the burden of uprightness. But righteousness cannot be at the cost of guiltless. Invalidation of deals is untenable. International and indigenous investors, who extended money, labors and time in the 2G and Coal allocation ventures, now stand crumbled. Wouldn’t the milieu be much auspicious in case the honorable court had also awarded compensation, by nationalizing the developed substructure, to make good the loss incurred by investors who followed the prescribed laws? Or at least, an option to pay the amount as per the prevailing market prices so as to carry on operations. Penalize dishonest officials and ministers rather. It is high time that the suffering of business houses be paid apt heed to. A commission, with ministers, fiscal and judicial experts, and veteran judges as members, must develop such a setup that decisions once taken by the GOI, and involving weighty allotments/ sanctions and grant of licenses be made irrevocable guaranteeing stable business atmosphere to investors.

69 thoughts on “Consensus between judiciary and legislature to boost investors’ trust

  1. Bhupesh Rathod

    Good article but synchronization of Judicial with legislature will never be possible till the nature of democracy changes. All pillars are watch dogs for each other.

    Judiciary tries to find out all solutions through law and make life of peoples with new new non senses.
    judiciary is very learned in law but little in social, religious, economical, familical, administrative, managerial, cultural and day to day aspects of Indians though enjoys power of as good as almighty GOD.
    The so called Democracy ends with the verdict of Apex Court which starts from street politics.

    Recent Judgement on the jurisdictional issue in the cases of sec 138 of NI Act, manifest respectful murder of natural justice only to relieve MM Courts from the never ending burden of pending cases.
    Efficiency of Lower court judges, Accused, Dupers, Cheaters, defaulters are favoured and blessed at the cost of Lenders,creditors, and all those who relied enacted law– that too with retrospective affect.

    I amuse the tendency and attitude of the learned( Merely law learned) JUdges of SC bench, who acted like great warrior to reduce burdens of lower court by spreading pending cases toPAN INdia by convenient interpretation which suits to them.

    People of INdia now feels and realize invisible rules of British Crown/East India Company through the structured kingdom i.e. Parliamentarian Democracy.

    India is not good place to do business but good place to ruin and destruct.


  2. G.S.Bhakkoo

    This is a matter of great concern and only high intellects can come to a conclusion.
    I agree that debating will not do any good, rather the government should form a committee to probe the matter.

  3. Dipika Govil

    More you discuss more will they come to know the problems of doing business in India.
    Share your knowledge, it is good, I believe judiciary will act on this.

  4. Visweswaran

    A good Article bringing out the issues to the front which is commonly ignored by Judiciary and Legislative when the process of correction / rectification is on.

    We could in build remedies and safety features in the system.

    Any public outlay should be subjected to scrutiny and review including Audit where applicable.
    Once the outlay is approved then the onus of executing and implementing is with the Bureaucrat.
    Litigations and Judgments should be made applicable in such a way that the responsibility of losses on account of the outlay is passed on to the relevant machinery like the approval committee or implementing committee and the persons concerned without the public having to again appeal for a relief.

  5. Ganga Tripathi

    Make in India programme of Indian government will see some setbacks because of the last decision, but clouds seem to be clear now, if something is not in social welfare, it will not be permitted.

  6. Harsh Vardhan Singh

    Corporate houses were not even at minute mistake,
    they just had to feel the fire because of corrupt officials and ministers.
    Judiciary should have noticed this too, which I think they failed to.

  7. Zarin Daruwala

    Justice Dattu should look over these problems.
    You cannot just cancel the contracts saying that they are not in favour of public.
    Contracts are binding if made with clear mind by the other party.

  8. Kusum Nainwal

    Government should, first of all, pay compensation to those who have lost money in these projects.
    Plus, they should make a provision so that in future any such losses should be made good by defaulting party.

  9. Manoj Gangwal

    I think even the businesses are at fault when they know
    that they are getting something at the price of peanut.
    They are too a partner in such actions.
    These verdicts will make them learn a lesson.

  10. Pushkar Shukla

    If someone asks me money to clear my file, what option do I have?
    Then why am I at fault if government did wrong.
    I am warning that if same conditions will prevail, India can never develop.

  11. Ganesh Sridhar

    Make it binding on government to pay for losses which are
    caused to corporates even when they follow the guidelines and pre-defined rules.
    Such deals should never be cancelled, there are many other ways.

  12. I.M.Bopanna

    It is very right that corporate houses should
    had been given a chance to pay as per the market price.
    Fresh allocation will be time and money consuming.
    Whatever spent by companies so far will become waste.

  13. Madhukarrao

    Good day! I just would like to give you a big thumbs up for your excellent information you have right here on this post.
    I will be coming back to your blog for more soon.

  14. Jasbir

    Thanks for the marvelous posting! I genuinely enjoyed reading it, you are a great author.
    I will always bookmark your blog and will come back very soon.
    I want to encourage that you continue your great work,have a nice day!

  15. Akhilesh

    Hello, I am so happy I found your weblog. I’m really appreciating the commitment you put into your site and in depth information you offer.
    This has been so particularly generous with people like you to supply openly all that
    most of us would’ve offered for sale for an e book in order to make some dough on their own,
    even more so seeing that you could possibly have tried it if you ever decided.

  16. Jaime

    You produced some decent points there. I looked on the net for the issue and identified most people will go together with along with your web site.

  17. Babbal

    These are in fact enormous ideas in concerning blogging. You have touched some nice things here. Any way keep up writing.

  18. Jayesh

    Woah! Ι’m reallly enjoying tɦe template/theme οf thiѕ website.
    ӏt’s simple, yеt effective. Α lot of times it’s tough to ցet that “perfect balance” betѡeеn usability ɑnd appearance.
    Ӏ must sаy you’ve ԁone a amazing job ԝith thіs.
    In addition, tɦe blog loads extremely fast fоr me on Chrome. Outstanding Blog!

  19. Abhijit

    I’m amazed, Ӏ mսst say. Rarely ԁo I cоmе acrߋss a blog that’s botth equally educative ɑnd amusing,
    and աithout ɑ doubt, үou’ve hit tҺe nail on the head.
    The problem іs something whіch not enough folks ɑге speaking intelligently ɑbout.
    I’m νery happy that I stumbled across Һis Ԁuring my search foг somethning relating to tɦіs.

  20. S.K. Lamba

    I’ve learn several just right stuff here. Certainly price bookmarking for revisiting.
    I wonder how much effort you set to create such a fantastic informative web site.

  21. N.B. Saxena

    Just spent a few very enjoyable minutes looking at the site. Excellent! Well done.
    Overall very good: clean, easy to navigate, informative and, importantly, interesting.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *